Ravenwood - 10/30/03 06:00 AM
I originally left this as a comment, but I wrote so much I decided to clean it up a bit and give it the full monty. Even though I'm a non-smoker, I disagree with the assertion that a patron's comfort should be of paramount importance with regards to smoking. While every business owner tries to appeal to the majority of customers, and while prohibiting smoking might please more than 50% of patrons, that doesn't necessarily translate into increased profits, for reasons that I'll explain.
When it comes to smoking, it is true that non-smokers may be more comfortable in a non-smoking environment. However, smokers seem to be more uncomfortable in a non-smoking environment than non-smokers are in a non-smoking environment. That is, smokers seem to be more fickle. (Addiction to nicotine may just have something to do with that.) In simple terms, that means that financially, you may be worse off appealing to a majority of customers (non smokers) if you're completely losing the minority (smokers). The reason being that although non-smokers prefer a non-smoking environment they aren't as likely to get up and leave as addiction-prone smokers are who barred from smoking.
That said, regardless of how the numbers work out, it should always be up to the business owner to decide which way he wants to cater his business. Having the government decide (or the majority) is tyranny. Even if the business owner wants to make a poor financial decision and cater to a niche (outside the mainstream) market, that's his business, not that of the government.
Having heard all the "there's no business anymore" stuff based on the bans, I was a bit shocked to discover that, at least in San Francisco, everything seemed pretty hopping.
And had some VERY clean indoor air. I wasn't chewing on it, and it was amazing - almost surreal.
hln
Posted by: hln at October 30, 2003 10:55 PMHeather,
Business still decreases in that many bars and restaurants are closing up shop. The decreased competition means that individual businesses may actually see their business increase. That is the evidence that anti-smokers usually hold up to justify their bans.
However, when you speak in terms of economies and jobs you have to take into consideration the number of businesses, not just how well one particular restaurant is doing.
Posted by: Ravenwood at October 30, 2003 11:05 PM(c) Ravenwood and Associates, 1990 - 2014