Ravenwood - 04/29/04 07:00 AM
Zell Miller is proposing the repeal of the 17th Amendment, reports World Net Daily.
Georgia Democratic Sen. Zell Miller is calling for the United States to restore the wishes of its Founding Fathers and empower state legislatures to appoint senators rather than be elected by voters.If that notion sounds familiar to you, it may be because you read about it right here almost 2 years ago.The retiring Miller, who has garnered attention over the past year with stinging critiques of his Democratic Party, believes rescinding the 17th Amendment would curb the power of special interests in Washington while increasing the power of state governments.
First, the popular election of Senators created all sorts of campain finance problems. With the passing of Seventeen, senators were immediately beholden to special interests, and large campaign contributors. While this influence was recently addressed with the McCain-Feingold law, both Senators and special interests have been busy finding ways around it.The movement to repeal Seventeen is nothing new. But this is the first I've heard of it from a sitting U.S. Senator (albeit a retiring one). Let's hope it picks up steam.Seventeen also dealt a serious blow to state's rights. With states removed from the federal process, the checks and balances the states had over the federal government was limited. The federal government not only began to expand uncontrollably, but it was empowered to impose its will over the individual states. Over time, mandates were imposed on the states, and the fed took control over some state institutions.
With the removal of checks and balances over the legislative branch, states were also removed from the federal judicial process. With states no longer having an influence on the selection of federal judges, Seventeen also destroyed the checks and balances over the judicial branch.
Category: Amendment of the Day
Comments (2) top link me
Which amendment gave women the vote?
Posted by: Ron Hardin at April 29, 2004 9:08 AMI'm glad to hear that someone of Mr. Miller's political stature is in support of the repeal. It's an excellent idea, and I've had something to say about it on more than one occasion.
It also has a snowball's chance in hell of happening. There's too much power wrapped up in the popular election of Senators. Once power is aquired, it is almost never given up.
Posted by: Kevin Baker at April 29, 2004 10:53 AM(c) Ravenwood and Associates, 1990 - 2014