Ravenwood - 07/13/05 07:30 AM
One out of every four Americans is of Irish descent, and I'm one of them. I must say that I'm more offended by the political correctness than anything.
Democratic candidate for mayor C. Virginia Fields is apologizing for using the term "paddy wagon" in an interview with NY1 last week.If you have to explain why it's insulting, is it really insulting?In Alabama on Friday, the Manhattan borough president talked about being arrested during a civil rights protest in 1963. In her comments, she described police vans as "paddy wagons" - a term that's considered offensive by some Irish-Americans. "Paddy" is a word used in the past as a pejorative to insult Irish people.
Back when I worked for a local steel maker (LTV), they sent all of their supervisors to sensitivity training, where they actually gave us a printed list of unacceptable words and phrases. Why I didn't keep the list, I'll never know, because it was great reading - a little something to offend everybody. The list made even all of the college-educated in the room turn into either Beavis or Butthead.
Anyhow, one of the terms we weren't supposed to use was, "flip chart". Yes, the paper tablet used in presentations. Nobody knew why, but it was later explained to us that "flip" is an insulting word for a Filipino. Who knew? It was good to know, however, since the steel mill in Cleveland was just teeming with Filipinos.
Man, we are so hung-up on words these days and nobody seems to care one bit about actual intent. Why is it so enjoyable to be offended these days? Is this just another symptom of our developing Victim Culture?
Posted by: roger at July 13, 2005 7:56 AMWell, we already knew that "niggardly" is a bad word. Here's a partial list of verboten cliches:
A chink in one's armor
Spic and span
To nip something in the bud
Faith and Begora, we'll march on New York City, and we'll do it every year on the same day, March 17th, until we get our reparations, and they are as follows:
1. Two cases of Guinness (bottles not cans) per week for life.
2. Two cases of Harp per week for life.
3. Six pounds of potatoes per week for life.
Is that really to much to ask?
My tongue has been removed from my cheek long enough to say that things like this will be the end of this country. That's the dumbest thing I've read in a while.
Posted by: John at July 13, 2005 9:53 AMActually, by PC standards the complaint is on the mark. But I suspect the complaint is a type of reminder that in the divisive world of liberal identity politics, we are all victims of hate crimes. Why should the Irish have to pass up a chance to play the victims of deep seated racism by the bigoted C. Virginia Fields?
Didn't anyone tell the PC police that the Irish are white?
Posted by: DaveJ at July 13, 2005 11:12 PMDaveJ: 120 years ago (say), a common joke in areas such as Boston was that an Irishman was a (N-word) turned inside out. It's a joke on the reddish coloring that more often occurs in the Irish - but it also brutally put them at the bottom of the social pecking order, and in fact the Irish weren't treated much better in Boston than blacks were in Mississippi. "Paddy wagon" (Paddy is from Patrick) probably reflected another edged joke - that Irishmen drank so much that they frequently had to be hauled off to jail by the van load.
But that was 120 years ago! And even back then, the cops stuffing drunks into the "paddy wagon" were likely to be Irish themselves. For several generations, Irish-Americans have been about as likely to be successful as other white Americans. I doubt that any American under 80 or 90 was ever told that he couldn't apply for a job, play in the park, or buy a house because he was of Irish descent. I very, very much doubt that "paddy" has any sting anymore.
Posted by: markm at July 15, 2005 11:49 AM(c) Ravenwood and Associates, 1990 - 2014